Catch and Martin sell the same idea in two price shapes: an assistant you hand tasks to in a chat. Catch charges one flat $99 a month with no lower tier for lighter use and no higher tier to grow into. Martin splits the same job between a capped Basic plan and an unrestricted Pro plan. People who leave one usually look at the other first, so this guide covers both: what each does well, the alternatives worth weighing, and the honest answer for readers whose real problem was never the request queue.
Why people look for an alternative
The reasons differ by product, and they point to different answers:
- Catch: one plan, no room to flex. Catch charges a flat $99 a month, billed monthly, with a 10-day free trial and shows no second tier, no per-seat pricing and no yearly discount. That’s simple, but there’s no cheaper entry point for occasional use and no way to lower the cost by committing longer.
- Martin: the cheaper plan is held back on purpose. Martin’s Basic tier runs on simpler models, limits how many tasks it works on at once, and caps proactive actions; Pro removes all three limits at a higher monthly price. There is no free plan either, only a short trial before billing starts.
- Either: the deeper problem wasn’t execution. Plenty of founders hand an assistant their to-do list, get genuinely useful execution, and still drop the ball — because what slipped was a promise made somewhere the assistant never looked.
For the first two, the table below is the answer. For the third, read where a request queue stops before switching apps again.
What Catch and Martin do well
Both earn their following in a specific lane: a stack of discrete, nameable tasks you’d rather delegate than do. Catch’s appeal is having nothing to decide — one price, no tier to revisit, a short trial before you commit. Martin’s appeal is choice — a cheaper plan for occasional, supervised use, and a full-price plan once you want it acting with fewer limits and more autonomy. Both are fairly priced for that job, and both reach well beyond email: Catch covers scheduling, travel bookings and calls, and you talk to it over Slack, Messages, email or a call; Martin manages calendar, inbox, texts and calls, and you can call, text or email it (catchagent.ai and trymartin.com/pricing, read 2026-11-12).
The alternatives, compared
Published prices below are taken from each vendor’s public pricing page as of late October 2026; plans and prices change, so verify before buying.
| Tool | Best for | Published price |
|---|---|---|
| Catch | one flat plan, nothing to compare | $99/mo, billed monthly, 10-day trial (catchagent.ai, read 2026-10-27) |
| Martin | a tiered chat-first assistant you hand tasks to directly | Basic $21/mo billed yearly or $35 billed monthly; Pro $30/mo yearly or $49 monthly (trymartin.com/pricing, read 2026-10-27) |
| Lindy | building your own cross-app automations, billed in credits | from $29.99/mo per active user for 3,000 credits (lindy.ai/pricing, re-read 2026-10-27) |
| Athena | a person doing the work, not software | $3,000/mo (athena.com/pricing, read 2026-10-22) |
| PILOT | the judgment layer across your whole world | free 14-day trial, then a company agreement |
Leaving Catch for Martin buys you a cheaper start and a higher ceiling, at the cost of a tier decision Catch never makes you face. Leaving Martin for Catch buys the opposite: one plan and nothing to compare, but no cheap entry for light use. Lindy sits apart from both: it charges by credits consumed, so cost scales with what you build rather than with a plan, at the price of designing and maintaining your own workflows. Athena is a managed human service for delegation that needs judgment or a phone call; what a person in that seat costs is broken down in the executive assistant cost guide.
Where a request queue stops
Catch and Martin work from your inbox, your calendar and the requests you send them. A promise you made out loud on a call, or an investor update you said you’d send by Friday, only reaches them if you turn it into a request, and the things you forget to hand over are exactly the ones that slip. A cheaper tier or a flatter price doesn’t change that; it’s how a request queue works.
The fix is a system that reads your mail, calendar, and meetings itself and keeps track of who is owed what, which is what an AI chief of staff does.
PILOT reads your mail, calendar, and meetings into one model of your commitments and briefs you every morning on what actually needs you.
- 7:00One move. Everything else stays tracked.
- Where it standsEvery project, with PILOT's summary and the next step.
- Your yesWhat PILOT drafts waits until you say so.
How to choose
- You want one plan and nothing to compare → Catch.
- You want a cheap start for occasional use, with room to remove limits later → Martin, Basic first, Pro when you need it.
- You want to design and maintain your own multi-step automations → Lindy.
- You need a person’s judgment, not just a booking or a call → a human assistant or Athena.
- Things are slipping that you never handed to anyone → neither Catch nor Martin will see them; look at a system that reads your channels for you.